Article · October 2026
Damian Maggio on Preferred vs. Common Stock: Why Share Class Matters in Private Companies
By Damian Maggio
When people hear a private company's valuation, they often assume every share is worth the same amount. In my experience, that is one of the most common misunderstandings in private markets. Inside most venture-backed companies, there are different classes of stock, and they do not carry the same rights.
Common stock is usually held by founders and employees, often through stock options or restricted stock. Preferred stock is usually issued to investors in funding rounds. Each new round can create a new series of preferred, each with its own terms.
Here are the terms I look at first.
Liquidation preference. This decides who gets paid first if the company is sold or wound down. Preferred holders are typically entitled to get back a set amount, often their original investment, before common holders receive anything. In a strong sale, that may make little difference. In a weaker one, it can mean common holders receive much less than the headline valuation suggests, or nothing.
Participating or non-participating. Some preferred stock collects its preference and then also shares in what is left. Other preferred must choose between its preference and converting to common. The difference can change payouts a great deal.
Seniority. When there are several series, later investors sometimes negotiate to be paid ahead of earlier ones. The order of the stack matters as much as the amounts.
Conversion. Preferred stock usually converts into common at an IPO. Conversion terms, and any adjustments tied to the IPO price, affect how ownership looks after listing.
Anti-dilution protection. If a company later raises money at a lower price, some preferred holders have terms that adjust their conversion rate. That protects them and shifts more dilution onto others.
Voting and protective provisions. Preferred holders often have approval rights over major decisions, such as new financings or a sale of the company.
This is also why a funding round's price per share is not the same as the value of a common share. Companies often value common stock separately, and the two can differ a lot.
For anyone considering a private-company investment, share class is only one piece of the risk. Private shares are illiquid and may be impossible to sell for years. Transfers are restricted under federal securities laws and company agreements. Information is limited, there is no market price, and valuations are uncertain. Private offerings are generally not reviewed by the SEC. Fees and other costs can reduce returns, later rounds can dilute existing holders, and investors can lose their entire investment.
The capital structure is in the documents. Before anyone thinks about a private company's valuation, it is worth knowing which class of stock they would hold and where it sits in line.
Damian Maggio writes about private markets and technology. This article is for informational purposes only and is not an offer or recommendation to buy or sell any security.